95 Phonics Core Program
2020

95 Phonics Core Program

Publisher
95 Percent Group
Subject
ELA
Grades
K-2
Report Release
01/22/2025
Review Tool Version
v2.0
Format
Supplemental: Foundational Skills Only

EdReports reviews of foundational skills supplements determine if a program meets, partially meets, or does not meet expectations for alignment to research-based practices and college and career ready standards. This rating encompasses all grades covered in the program.

Alignment (Gateway 1)
Partially Meets Expectations

Materials must meet expectations for standards alignment in order to be reviewed for usability. This rating encompasses all grades covered in the program.

Usability (Gateway 2)
NE = Not Eligible. Product did not meet the threshold for review.
Not Eligible
Key areas of interest

This score is the sum of all points available for all foundational skills components across all grades covered in the program.

The maximum available points depends on the review tool used and the number of grades covered.

Foundational Skills
146/198

This score represents an average across grade levels reviewed for: integrated reading, writing, speaking, listening, and language, and promotion of mastery of grade-level standards by the end of the year.

Building Knowledge
NC = Not Claimed. The publisher does not claim that this component is addressed in the materials.
NC
Our Review Process

Learn more about EdReports’ educator-led review process

Learn More

About This Report

Report for 1st Grade

Alignment Summary

The Grade 1 materials partially meet the expectations for alignment to research-based practices and standards for foundational skills instruction. The materials provide structured instruction in phonemic awareness, phonics, and word analysis, emphasizing explicit teaching, cumulative practice, and decodable texts. The materials include well-designed phonics lessons and varied syllabication and morpheme activities. However, high-frequency word instruction is inconsistent, fluency development is limited, and assessments of all skills are limited.

1st Grade
Alignment (Gateway 1)
Partially Meets Expectations
Usability (Gateway 2)
Not Rated
Overview of Gateway 1

Alignment to Research-Based Practices and Standards for Foundation Skills Instruction

The materials provide a structured approach to phonemic awareness with a clear scope and sequence, supported by teacher modeling, word segmentation, and sound-spelling mapping. However, oral blending practice is limited, and corrective feedback guidance is unclear. Assessments are minimal and lack direct evaluation of phonemic awareness skills.

Phonics instruction follows a research-based sequence, emphasizing explicit modeling, blending, and decoding activities. Regular review lessons and cumulative practice reinforce learning, supported by decodable texts and readers. However, formative assessments are limited, and instructional next steps are not clearly outlined.

While the materials offer some explicit high-frequency word instruction, the approach is inconsistent, with only 41 words introduced throughout the year. Syllabication and morpheme analysis are well-supported through varied routines, but word recognition assessments are lacking. Guidance for reteaching and next steps is minimal.

Fluency instruction is minimal, with limited focus on accuracy, automaticity, and prosody. Activities rely on repeated readings of phonics-based texts, with minimal opportunities for students to hear fluent reading. Fluency assessment tools are limited, and progress monitoring lacks detailed instructional support.

Criterion 1.1: Phonemic Awareness

08/16

Materials emphasize explicit, systematic instruction of research-based and/or evidence-based phonemic awareness.

The materials provide a structured and evidence-based approach to phonemic awareness with a scope and sequence that outlines skill development. Most lessons emphasize phonemic awareness, including activities like using Elkonin boxes and chips for word segmentation. Instruction is systematic and explicit, with repeated teacher modeling and guidance for isolating and manipulating sounds. However, opportunities for students to orally blend phonemes into words are limited, and the materials lack clear guidance for providing corrective feedback. Students practice connecting sounds to letters through guided and independent activities, utilizing lesson presentation slides and the Student Workbook. Teacher scripts on the back of Sound-Spelling Cards provide guidance for phoneme articulation, but lesson plans do not specify when these cards should be used. Assessment opportunities for phonemic awareness are also limited, with only five unit assessments, one of which includes identifying words with target phonemes. While sound-spelling mapping activities encourage segmentation, phonemic awareness is not directly assessed.

Indicator 1C
02/04

Scope and sequence clearly delineate the sequence in which phonemic awareness skills are to be taught, with a clear, evidence-based explanation for the expected hierarchy of phonemic awareness competence.

The materials contain a clear, evidence-based explanation for the expected sequence for teaching phonemic awareness skills. The Scope and Sequence provides an outline for phonemic awareness skill development. The majority of lessons focus on the development of phonemic awareness skills. Phonological awareness warm-ups are included in lessons but do not correspond to the phonics topic. However, students practice using Elkonin boxes and chips when learning to segment a word to spell it. 

Materials contain a clear, evidence-based explanation for the expected sequence for teaching phonemic awareness skills.

  • In the Introduction, the materials state that the program is research-based using studies by the National Reading Panel report and David Kilpatrick’s 2015 book, Essentials of Assessing, Preventing, and Overcoming Reading Difficulties.

  • In Introduction, Phonological Awareness, the materials acknowledge the importance of phonological awareness skills in learning to read, which is why they include a two-minute warm-up in all Kindergarten through grade 3 materials. The materials state that as lessons progress, the concepts also progress towards advanced phonemic awareness tasks such as adding, deleting, and substituting initial and final phonemes.

Materials have a cohesive sequence of phonemic awareness instruction based on the expected hierarchy to build toward students’ immediate application of the skills. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Introduction, Scope and Sequence, the materials include a scope and sequence that outlines the following progression in phonemic awareness instruction:

    • Lesson 1: Review of blending and identifying initial sounds 

    • Lessons 2-7: Syllables, onset-rime, and phoneme segmentation 

    • Lessons 8-11: Phoneme addition and segmentation 

    • Lessons 12-21: Phoneme addition, deletion, and substitution 

    • Lessons 22-30: Phoneme addition, deletion, and substitution within a blend 

Materials attend to developing phonemic awareness skills and avoid spending excess time on phonological sensitivity tasks. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • The Scope and Sequence indicates Lessons 1-5 focus on phonological sensitivity tasks, whereas Lessons 6-30 attend to developing phonemic awareness skills. 

  • In Lesson 6, Day 2, the Teacher Tip states that the Phonological Awareness Warm-Up in the lesson has shifted from the syllable-level review in Lessons 2-3 and onset substitution in Lessons 4-5 to phoneme segmentation. The box says that syllable and onset-rime awareness should be developed in preschool, and kindergarten students should be gaining mastery in detecting and manipulating phonemes. The box indicates that all phonological awareness warm-ups from Lesson 6 forward will be at the phoneme level, increasing in difficulty throughout the lessons. 

Materials do not contain a phonemic awareness sequence of instruction and practice aligned to the phonics scope and sequence. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • Each lesson starts with a Phonological or Phonemic Awareness Warm-Up that lasts two minutes. The skills and words used during this warm-up do not specifically align with the phonics scope and sequence. However, in some lessons, there is a phonemic awareness activity that supports students in reading and/or spelling the words for the newly taught pattern. For example:

    • In Lesson 5, Day 2, the phonics objective is to understand closed syllable short e patterns. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment the words yes, web, bit, beg, red, and net using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes. 

    • In Lesson 12, Day 3, the phonics objective is to understand the consonant digraph ch. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment using Elkonin boxes the words champ, chin, ranch, cab, much, and fact using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes. 

    • In Lesson 20, Day 3, the phonics objective is to understand the long u silent e pattern. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment the words rude, June, tube, globe, nut, and dune using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes.

Indicator 1D
02/04

Materials include systematic and explicit instruction in phonemic awareness with repeated teacher modeling.

The materials include systematic and explicit instruction in phonemic awareness with repeated teacher modeling; however, there is limited evidence of students orally blending phonemes to form words. Materials provide the teacher with instruction in sounds, including isolating and manipulating sounds. However, the materials do not provide clear guidance for corrective feedback for phonemic awareness. 

Materials provide the teacher with limited systematic, explicit instruction in sounds (phonemes). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • RF.1.2a Distinguish long from short vowel sounds in spoken single-syllable words.

    • In Lesson 16, Day 3, the teacher uses phonics chips to model segmenting phonemes. The teacher introduces the green chip and tells students that the green chip will represent long vowels in the silent-e pattern. The teacher models using chips to segment the word plate, using a green chip for the /ā/ sound. The teacher guides students to practice with the words grave, ship, shake, crab, and lame, using green chips for long vowels and red chips for short vowels. 

    • In Lesson 17, Day 3, the teacher models sound spelling with phonics chips to segment phonemes. The teacher reviews the green chip and tells students that the green chip will represent long vowels in the silent-e pattern. The teacher models using chips to segment the word life, using a green chip for the long /i/ sound. The teacher guides students to practice with the words life, five, ship, drive, hint, and smile, using green chips for long vowels and red chips for short vowels.

  • RF.1.2b Orally produce single-syllable words by blending sounds (phonemes), including consonant blends. 

    • No evidence found

  • RF.1.2c Isolate and pronounce initial, medial vowel, and final sounds (phonemes) in spoken single-syllable words.

    • In Lesson 11, Day 3, the teacher uses phonics chips to model segmenting phonemes. The teacher says the word scrap, then models finger-stretching the word into phonemes /s/ /k/ /r/ /ă/ /p/. The teacher guides students to identify the first sound and then places a phonics chip in the first box. The teacher repeats the second, third, fourth, and final sounds, placing a chip in the corresponding box for each phoneme. 

    • In Lesson 20, Day 3, the teacher models using phonics chips to segment the sounds in the word rude. The teacher finger stretches the individual phonemes, counts the number of phonemes, dots the appropriate number of boxes, and states the first sound heard as /r/, the middle sound as long /u/, and the last sound as /d/. The teacher places the corresponding chips in the appropriate boxes and states the syllable as silent-e.

  • RF.1.2d Segment spoken single-syllable words into their complete sequence of individual sounds (phonemes).

    • In Lesson 6, Day 1, the teacher explains that the students will practice phoneme segmentation in a word, and the teacher models finger-stretching. The teacher says the word sit and stretches a finger for each sound /s/ /short i/ /t/.

    • In Lesson 7, Day 2, the teacher models segmenting the word set into phonemes using phonics chips and boxes. The teacher models finger-stretching the word, counting the sounds, and placing a colored chip for each sound, using a blue chip for consonant sounds and a red chip for the short vowel sound. 

Materials provide the teacher with examples for instruction in sounds (phonemes). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 6, Day 1, the materials provide the teacher with the word sit to model segmenting and the words red and hop to guide students in segmenting the words into phonemes. The materials include the following examples for the teacher to guide student practice: as, dad, dim, jog, bun, gap, in, job, wet, yum, rib, at, vet, cut, us, and tip. 

  • In Lesson 14, Day 3, the materials provide the teacher with the word quick to model phoneme segmentation with phonics chips. The materials include examples for the teacher to guide student practice, including quiz, spell, press, fix, and next

  • In Lesson 25, Day 3, the materials provide the teacher with the word blind to model phoneme segmentation with phonics chips. The materials include examples for the teacher to guide student practice, including find, mild, grind, close, shut, and thing

Materials include teacher guidance for corrective feedback when needed for students. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • No evidence found

Indicator 1E
04/04

Materials include daily, brief lessons in phonemic awareness.

The materials include opportunities for students to practice connecting sounds to letters in the context of guided and independent practice using the lesson presentation slides and the Student Workbook. The materials include teacher scripts for demonstrating articulation of all phonemes introduced on the back of the Sound-Spelling Cards; however, the lesson plans do not indicate when the teacher should use the cards in instruction.

Daily phonemic awareness instruction correlates to the phonics portion of the lesson (phoneme-grapheme correspondence). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 8, Day 3, the phonics objective is to understand initial and final s-blends. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment the words just, skip, vest, stud, rust, and slop using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes. 

  • In Lesson 19, Day 3, the phonics objective is to understand the long o silent e pattern. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment the words slope, pope, not, chose, slop, and note using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes. 

  • In Lesson 24, Day 3, the phonics objective is to understand the phonogram patterns all, oll, and alk. At the beginning of the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students segment the words mall, troll, chalk, mold, chest, and tall using colored-coded phonics chips and boxes. 

Materials include opportunities for students to practice connecting sounds to letters. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 1, Day 5, students identify the beginning sound in the words zipper, queen, rug, van, yo-yo, and up in the Student Workbook. Students say the word, say the first sound, say the letter name, and then repeat the sound while writing the letter next to the picture of the word. 

  • In Lesson 15, Day 1, students look at Key Cards for the words chair, branch, shoe, brush, thumb, mouth, and whale. Students say the keyword and then say the sound of the underlined digraph. 

  • In Lesson 27, Day 3, students complete a Sound-Spelling Mapping Activity in the Student Workbook. Students finger stretch the dictated word fill, count the sounds, place a dot in the bottom right corner of each box they will need, and then write the letters, each sound in its own box. Students repeat with the words coil, clay, hope, paw, and joy

Materials include directions to the teacher for demonstrating how to pronounce each phoneme (articulation/mouth formation). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • Articulation scripts are included on the Sound-Spelling Cards. However, the materials do not reference when to use the cards.

    • On the Sound-Spelling Card /sh/, the back of the card provides the teacher with a script for the articulation of the sound. The teacher says, “When I make the /sh/ sound, my teeth are together. My lips are puckered and look like fish lips. I put my hand on my throat. /sh/ I don’t feel a vibration. /sh/ is an unvoiced sound.”

    • On the Sound-Spelling Card /oll/, the back of the card provides the teacher with a script for the articulation of the sound. The teacher says, “When I say /oll/, my mouth is open and rounded, the first sound begins like /ō/. As I finish, my tongue moves toward the roof of my mouth for /l/. The vowel changes as my mouth moves toward the /l/ sound.”

Indicator 1F
00/04

Materials regularly and systematically offer assessment opportunities that measure student progress of phonemic awareness (as indicated by the program scope and sequence).

The materials include limited assessment opportunities in the area of phonemic awareness. The materials include five Unit Assessments. One assessment includes items in which students identify words with a spoken initial or final target phoneme. While the assessments include sound-spelling mapping items that encourage students to segment spoken words to spell them in sound mapping boxes, the phonemic awareness skill is not directly assessed. 

Materials do not regularly and systematically provide a variety of assessment opportunities over the course of the year to demonstrate students’ progress toward mastery and independence in phonemic awareness. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Assessment 1, Section C, Sound-Spelling Mapping, the teacher assesses the identification of individual phonemes in closed syllable words and the accurate encoding of the graphemes that represent each phoneme. The teacher models how to use the sound-spelling mapping paper to identify the number of phonemes found in a word and write the grapheme that represents that phoneme. Students identify the phonemes and write the graphemes in the sound-spelling map for each of the following words: dig, sat, top, jug, met. 

Assessment materials provide teachers and students with limited information concerning students’ current skills/level of understanding of phonemic awareness. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Assessment Overview, the materials indicate that if a student misses more than one response in a section, the teacher should “check the student’s understanding of the skill with additional items that are similar to those in the assessment.”

Materials do not support teachers with instructional suggestions for assessment-based steps to help students to progress toward mastery in phonemic awareness. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Assessment Overview, the materials indicate that if less than 80% of students respond correctly to an individual assessment section, the teacher should provide additional teaching of the specific skill assessed during Tier 1 instruction.

Criterion 1.2: Phonics (Decoding and Encoding)

28/32

Materials emphasize explicit, systematic instruction of research-based and/or evidence-based phonics.

The materials provide a well-structured and research-supported scope and sequence for phonics instruction, progressing from simple to more complex skills and incorporating high-utility patterns and phonics generalizations. Citing research from David Kilpatrick and internal studies, the program uses a research-based pacing model, with 20-minute lessons that include explicit teacher modeling, blending, and segmenting routines, as well as dictation and corrective feedback. The materials avoid teaching using the three-cueing system. Regular review lessons and consistent routines, such as word chaining, sound-spelling mapping, and word pattern reading, offer students ample opportunities to practice decoding and encoding. Spelling rules and generalizations are systematically taught and reinforced through varied activities like dictation and pattern analysis. Decodable texts aligned to the phonics sequence are utilized for repeated reading practice, and 20 Decodable Duos readers support skill acquisition. However, the materials lack variety in formative assessments and progress monitoring tools, relying primarily on summative assessments and optional spelling tests. While assessment materials provide insight into student progress, they offer limited guidance for instructional next steps.

Indicator 1G
04/04

Scope and sequence clearly delineate an intentional sequence in which phonics skills are to be taught, with a clear evidence-based explanation for the order of the sequence.

The materials include a clear scope and sequence of phonics skills with explanations for the order of the phonics sequence. The materials cite their own research and study groups as the basis for the explanation of the order of the phonics sequence, as well as research from David Kilpatrick. The scope and sequence includes a cohesive, intentional sequence of phonics instruction, from simple to more complex skills, and practice to build toward the application of skills. Phonics instruction is based on high utility patterns as well as specific phonics generalizations.

Materials have a clear, research-based explanation for the order of the phonics sequence. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Teacher’s Edition, Introduction, Alignment with the Science of Reading, the materials state that the guiding principles of the curriculum are based on the studies cited in David Kilpatrick’s 2015 book Essentials of Assessing, Preventing, and Overcoming Reading Difficulties. One of these principles is that “effective phonics instruction follows a prescribed sequence that progresses from simple to complex.” The materials indicate that the phonics skills progression is designed so that each lesson builds on earlier mastered concepts. 

  • In the Teacher’s Edition, Introduction, “Effective phonics instruction follows a prescribed sequence that progresses from simple to complex. Our phonics products follow a skills progression that is defined by 95 Percent Group’s phonics continuum so that each lesson builds on earlier mastered concepts.” 

Materials clearly delineate a scope and sequence with a cohesive, intentional sequence of phonics instruction, from simpler to more complex skills, and practice to build toward the application of skills. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Introduction, Scope and Sequence, the materials include a scope and sequence that outlines the following progression in phonics instruction:

    • Lesson 1 Kindergarten review of letters, sounds and blending 

    • Lessons 2 -6 CVC words

      • Lesson 2 Short a 

      • Lesson 3 Short

      • Lesson 4 Short o 

      • Lesson 5 Short e 

      • Lesson 6 Short u

    • Lessons 8 - 11 Consonant Blends

      • Lesson 8 Initial/Final s-blends 

      • Lesson 9 Initial/Final l- and t-blends

      • Lesson 10 Initial r-blends 

      • Lesson 11 Initial 3-letter blends

    • Lesson 12 - 13 Consonant Digraphs

      • Lesson 12 Digraphs ch and sh 

      • Lesson 13 Digraphs th, wh, c

    • Lesson 14 Floss Rule, qu, and Final x 

    • Lesson 16 - 20 Long vowel silent-e

      • Lesson 16 Long a

      • Lesson 17 Long i 

      • Lesson 18 Long e

      • Lesson 19 Long o 

      • Lesson 20 Long u 

    • Lesson 22 - 24 Phonograms

      • Lesson 22 ang, ing, ong and ink, ank, onk 

      • Lesson 23 ild, ind, old, olt, and ost 

      • Lesson 24 all, oll, alk 

    • Lesson 26 - 27 Predictable vowel teams

      • Vowel teams ee, igh, oa, oe 

      • Vowel teams ai, ay, oi, oy, au, aw 

    • Lesson 28 Unpredictable vowel teams

      • 2 sounds for ea and ow 

    • Lesson 29 Vowel-r: ar, or, and er/ir/ur

    • Lesson 30 Simple closed-closed multisyllable

Phonics instruction is based in high utility patterns and/or specific phonics generalizations. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Teacher’s Edition, Introduction, Scope and Sequence, the materials show that the program is organized using high utility patterns and specific phonics generalizations. Lessons 1-7 review short vowel CVC patterns. Lessons 8-11 introduce consonant blends. Lessons 12-15 introduce consonant digraphs. Lessons 16-21 introduce the long vowel silent-e pattern. Lessons 22-25 introduce phonograms. Lessons 26-30 introduce   predictable and unpredictable vowel teams and vowel-r patterns.

  • In Lesson 4, Day 4, the teacher provides instruction for reading and spelling words with the short o sound. The teacher says, “The vowel letter o represents the /o/ sounds, which is a short vowel sound. When a word has 1 vowel letter followed by 1 or more consonants, the vowel is short.” The teacher guides students to find the vowel in words, and identify the short o vowel pattern.

  • In Lesson 15, Day 4, the teacher is provided with three rules for inflected endings. 

    • Rule 1 - For words spelled with 2 or more consonants at the end, add -er, -est

    • Rule 2 - For words spelled with y at the end, drop the last y and add i before adding -er, -est

    • Rule 3 - For words spelled with a single vowel followed by 1 consonant, double the final consonant before adding -er, -est

Indicator 1H
04/04

Materials are absent of the three-cueing system.

Materials do not contain elements of instruction that are based on the three-cueing system for teaching decoding.

  • Materials do not contain lessons or resources that include the three-cueing system.

Indicator 1I
04/04

Materials, questions, and tasks provide reasonable pacing where phonics (decoding and encoding) skills are taught one at a time and allot time where phonics skills are practiced to automaticity, with cumulative review.

The materials use reasonable research-based pacing for the introduction of phonics skills over the year. At the lesson pacing level, the materials indicate that each lesson is designed to be taught in 20 minutes, and the teacher’s edition includes specific timing for each portion of the lesson. Each lesson contains ample and varied opportunities for students to practice newly-taught phonics skills. Materials include periodic cumulative review lessons, including a beginning-of-the-year kindergarten skills review. 

Materials include reasonable pacing of newly taught phonics skills. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • According to the Scope and Sequence, pacing of newly taught phonics skills includes:

    • In Lessons 2-7 (6 weeks), the materials review and practice short vowel CVC patterns.

    • In Lessons 8-11 (4 weeks), the materials introduce initial and final s-blends, l-blends, and t-blends, initial r-blends, and initial 3-letter blends. 

    • In Lessons 12-15 (4 weeks), the materials introduce consonant digraphs ch, sh, th, wh, and ck, the Floss Rule, qu, and final x

    • In Lessons 16-21 (6 weeks), the materials introduce long vowel final e patterns one vowel at a time. The materials practice each pattern for one week in the following order, followed by a week of review: a, i, e, o, u

    • In Lessons 22-25 (4 weeks), the materials introduce the phonograms ang, ing, ong, ink, ank, onk, ild, ind, old, olt, ost, all, oll, and alk.

    • In Lessons 26-30 (4 weeks), the materials introduce predictable vowel teams ee, igh, oa, oe, ai/ay, oi/oy, and au/aw, unpredictable vowel teams ea and ow, and r-controlled vowels ar, or, and er/ir/ur

The lesson plan design allots time to include sufficient student practice to work towards automaticity. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 23, Day 1, the learning objective for the week is for students to “demonstrate understanding of the phonogram patterns ild, ind, old, olt, and ost by correctly identifying, reading, and writing pattern words in isolation and in passages.” In the Word Sort portion of the lesson, students practice in the Student Workbook by sorting the words child, bolt, find, most, blank, bind, gold, colt, old, and wild into columns labeled with the phonograms and a column for no phonogram pattern. In the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students use sound mapping boxes to segment and then spell the following words: colt, mild, code, blind, most, and scold. In the Passage Reading portion of the lesson, students scan the passage Holding Colt to Task and underline words with the target phonograms. 

  • In Lesson 23, Day 2, students use a list of the following words to identify the number of vowels, say the phonogram or syllable type while showing the matching gesture, saying the sound of the phonogram or vowel, and then reading the word. In the Pattern and Contrast Words portion of the lesson, students identify and whisper the phonogram pattern or syllable type and make the matching gesture, write the word under the column with the matching heading, and whisper read the word. In the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students use sound mapping boxes to segment and then spell the following words: child, host, rind, jolt, vote, old. In the Passage Reading portion of the lesson, students read the underlined words containing the target phonogram patterns in the passage Holding Colt to Task and then read the passage as a whole. 

  • In Lesson 23, Day 3, students chorally read the following words, making a phonogram gesture or the gesture for a closed or silent-e syllable as they read each word: blind, scold, colt, must, sob, hold, host, chip, told, kind, dot, think, hole, post, bold, grind, wild, cold, mind, bolt. In the Sound-Spelling Mapping portion of the lesson, students use phonics chips to segment and then spell the words. In the Passage Reading portion of the lesson, students scan the passage Bold Rush for Gold and underline words with the target phonograms. 

  • In Lesson 23, Day 4, students use a Sound Bank to complete word ladders for the phonograms ild, ind, old, olt, and ost, completing three words for each phonogram. In the Passage Reading portion of the lesson, students read the underlined words containing the target phonogram patterns in the passage Bold Rush for Gold and then read the passage as a whole. 

  • In Lesson 23, Day 5, students participate in a one-minute timed reading of a word list containing the following words: mind, old, hold, child, host, mild, bolt, told, cold, sold, wild, post, find, kind, bind, colt. Then students participate in a one-minute timed reading of phrases, using a set of 16 phrases containing the week’s target phonograms. In the Sentence Dictation portion of the lesson, students write the dictated sentences, Post a stake at the mine you find, The bold child likes to bolt, and Where did you find that gold? In the Passage Reading portion of the lesson, students re-read the passages Holding Colt to Task and Bold Rush for Gold

Materials contain distributed, cumulative, and interleaved opportunities for students to practice and review all previously learned grade-level phonics. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 7, the materials include a five-day cumulative review of previously taught letter-sound correspondences: a, e, i, o, u . The learning objective for this review week states, “Students demonstrate understanding of all short vowel, and closed syllables by correctly identifying, reading, and writing pattern words in isolation and passages. Also, students demonstrate an early understanding of inflected ending -ed and simple closed-closed multisyllabic words.” 

  • In Lesson 15, the materials include a one-week cumulative review of previously taught phonics skills. The learning objective for this review week states, “Students demonstrate understanding of consonant digraphs in closed syllable words, as well as an understanding of simple multisyllabic words, by correctly identifying, reading, and writing pattern words in isolation and passage.” Consonant digraphs were taught in Lessons 12-14.

Indicator 1J
04/04

Materials include systematic and explicit phonics instruction with repeated teacher modeling.

Materials contain explicit instructions for systematic and repeated teacher modeling of newly-taught phonics patterns. Lessons include blending and segmenting practice using structured, consistent blending routines with teacher modeling. Lessons include dictation of words and sentences using the newly taught phonics pattern(s). Materials include teacher guidance for corrective feedback when needed for students.

Materials contain explicit instructions for systematic and repeated teacher modeling of newly-taught phonics patterns. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • RF.1.3a Know the spelling-sound correspondences for common consonant digraphs.

    • In Lesson 11, Day 1, the teacher explains that consonant digraphs have one sound spelled with two consonants side by side and that digraphs can be found at the initial or final position in words. The teacher displays the word cash and cast on the interactive slides along with a chart with the picture and words chair, branch, shoe, brush, and the no symbol meaning the word does have a consonant digraph. The teacher models the word sorting routine for the word cash by determining if the word has a consonant digraph ch or sh and if so, determining if the consonant digraph is at the initial or final part of the word. For the word cash, the teacher writes the word under the word/picture of brush. For the word cast, the teacher writes it under the no symbol since the word does not have a consonant digraph.

    • In Lesson 13, Day 1, the teacher tells students that a consonant digraph has one sound with two consonants side by side; the letters are not pronounced with two separate sounds. The teacher displays the digraph th and the words thin and path, with the digraph highlighted, and tells students that th can be found in the initial or final position of a word. The teacher displays the digraph wh and the word whisk and tells students that wh is only found in the initial position in words. The teacher displays the digraph ck and the word duck and tells students that ck is only found in the final position. 

  • RF.1.3b Decode regularly spelled one-syllable words.

    • In Lesson 2, Day 2, the teacher reviews the /ă/ sound and explains that nasal a words follow the short a pattern, except that the final /m/ or /n/ changes the sound of the a. The teacher models decoding the word man. The teacher displays the word and touches the vowel, identifying one vowel in the word and one consonant after the vowel. The teacher identifies the syllable type as closed and vowel sound as nasal /ăn/, then reads the word man

    • In Lesson 8, Day 2, the teacher models decoding the word fast. The teacher first finds the vowel (a) and identifies the syllable type (closed, one vowel followed by one or more consonants). Next, the teacher whispers the vowel sound /ǎ/, then finds two consonants after the vowels, and identifies that the word has a final s-blend. Finally, the teacher slides a finger under the word and whispers fast.

  • RF.1.3c Know final -e and common vowel team conventions for representing long vowel sounds.

    • In Lesson 17, Day 1, the teacher explains that long vowel silent e words have a single vowel, a single consonant, and e at the end and that the vowel sound is long and the e at the end is silent and not pronounced. The teacher models sorting words under the long i column with a picture of ice or short i column with a picture of itch. The teacher projects the word ride and points to the vowels i and e explaining that the word follows the long vowel silent e pattern and places the word under the long i ice column.

    • In Lesson 26, Day 1, the teacher explains that a vowel team has two or three letters side by side that are pronounced as one vowel sound. The teacher reviews the week’s vowel team spellings and their keywords (ee-/ē/ eel, igh-/īi/ night, oe-/ō/ toe, oa-/ō/ oat.) The teacher then projects the word foam and explains that she is going to look for the ee, igh, oa, and oe vowel teams. The teacher finds the vowel letters oa and explains that the word has the vowel team oa pattern.

  • RF.1.3d Use knowledge that every syllable must have a vowel sound to determine the number of syllables in a printed word.

    • In Lesson 2, Day 1, the teacher says, “A syllable is a word or a part of a word. All syllables have at least 1 vowel sound. There are 6 syllable types. Learning all 6 syllable types is the key to reading more accurately and fluently.” The teacher then introduces the closed-syllable type with accompanying hand gestures of a closed fist, saying that closed syllables have one vowel letter followed by one or more consonants, with the vowel sound being short.

    • In Lesson 25, Day 2, the teacher projects the word tadpole and models reading multisyllabic words by using both hands to find the vowels in each syllable, pointing to the letter a and the letter o, explaining that the e at the end is silent. Next, the teacher draws a line under the vowel sounds and explains that this word has two syllables because it has two vowel sounds. The teacher continues to divide the word into syllables and read the word.

  • RF.1.3e Decode two-syllable words following basic patterns by breaking the words into syllables.

    • In Lesson 15, Day 4, the teacher displays the word himself, then points to and underlines the two vowels. The teacher tells students the word has two syllables because it has two vowel sounds. The teacher models dividing the word by identifying the syllable type to decode the syllables and read the word. The teacher repeats the process, guiding students to decode the word chipmunk

    • In Lesson 21, Day 4, the teacher displays the word remote and models how to find the vowels in the word by using two hands to point to the vowels. The teacher explains that the first o and e have a sound, but the e is silent at the end. The teacher then models counting the number of consonants between the vowels by saying only one consonant is seen m. The teacher explains the first syllable, re is open since there is not a consonant following the vowel. The teacher says that the word is divided between the letters e and m. The teacher explains that the first e is long since it is in an open syllable and that the second syllable type is long vowel silent e, that the o says its name and the syllable is mote. Lastly, the teacher reads the whole word remote. 

  • RF.1.3f Read words with inflectional endings.

    • In Lesson 15, Day 4, the teacher reviews a table that explains the rules for adding the endings -er and -est to an adjective. The teacher displays the word big and models finding the vowel. The teacher states the word has a single vowel followed by one consonant and follows rule 3 on the table, which indicates the consonant will be doubled before adding -er or -est. The teacher then writes the word bigger under the “Base word + er” column and biggest under the “Base word + est” column and reads each word: big, bigger, biggest.

    • In Lesson 21, Day 1, the teacher tells students that the -ed ending on a verb indicates it happened in the past. The teacher displays the spelling rules for adding -ed to the end of a word, then models changing like to liked by sliding a finger under the word and whispering liked

Lessons include blending and segmenting practice using structured, consistent blending routines with teacher modeling. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 8, Day 2, the teacher models segmenting and encoding the word spot. The teacher finger-stretches the word, counts the sounds, and marks four corresponding boxes, saying each sound while marking the boxes. The teacher names the letters that represent each sound and writes them in the boxes. The teacher identifies the syllable type and the initial s-blend, says the sounds, and then reads the word.  

  • In Lesson 30, Day 5, the teacher reviews the routine for reading multisyllabic words.” The teacher displays the word zigzag and says, “I use both hands to find the vowels in each syllable. I point to the letter i with my left pointer finger, and the letter a with my right pointer finger. There are 2 vowel sounds. Next, I underline the vowels. This word has 2 syllables because it has 2 vowel sounds. I underline the vowel letters, i and a. I look for the number of consonants between the vowels. There are 2- g and z. When there are 2 consonants between the 2 vowels, divide the word between them. I draw a line between g and z.” The teacher guides students to do the next step together, read the first syllable while covering the second syllable and the second syllable while covering the first. Last, the teacher guides students to read the word zigzag. Students then practice the routine with the words himself, window, sunlamp, mistake, and gossip. 

Lessons include dictation of words and phrases using the newly taught phonics pattern(s). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 15, Day 2, the teacher dictates the words shop, chip, quick, dash, then, split, and munch for students to practice reviewing the consonant digraphs ch, sh, th, and wh.

  • In Lesson 19, Day 5, the lesson includes sentence dictation for the sentences, Hope made notes for her pals, Some homes are shaped like cones, and The mole ran down the hole. These sentences practice the lesson’s target phonics objective of understanding the long o silent -e pattern. 

Materials include teacher guidance for corrective feedback when needed for students. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In the Ancillary materials, Teacher’s Material, the Corrective Feedback for Positive Achievement document provides examples for teachers on how to give corrective feedback for one-syllable and multisyllable words.

Indicator 1K
02/04

Materials include frequent practice opportunities for students to decode and encode words that consist of common and newly-taught sound and spelling patterns.

The materials include consistent routines for students to practice decoding and encoding common and newly-taught sound-spelling patterns. The recurring routines provide ample varied practice opportunities to build accuracy and automaticity, including word chaining, word pattern reading, sound-spelling mapping with and without phonics chips, word reading fluency practice, and word sorts. However, student-guided practice and independent practice of blending sounds using the sound-spelling pattern(s) is not varied or frequent. 

Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to decode words with taught phonics patterns. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 6, Day 2, students read ten CVC words. For each word, students point to the vowel, say the number of vowels, indicate whether the vowel is followed by one or more consonants, say the syllable type and show the gesture, say the vowel sound, and then read the word. Words include fun, not, gut, did, get, pin, rat, nut, cup, tub. 

  • In Lesson 10, the Initial r-blends pattern is introduced. On Day 1, students read the story Brad Can Brag, which contains the following words aligned to the phonics pattern: Brad, drab, grub, brag, drag, trap, bred, drop, trek, brim, fret, trim, crib, grab, crop, grin. There is one word in the three sentences that uses the spelling pattern: cube. On Day 2, students reread the story Brad Can Brag. On Day 3, students practice reading the following list of words: crop, best, fret, bed, grab, prop, crab, grunt, drop, Brad, trek, drag, rot, trip, rid, glam, brag, dug, crust, crib. On Day 4, students read the informational passage A Trap for a Frog, and the following words with the phonics pattern are present: brag, grab, trek, bred, grin, trip, brim, grip, drag, grub, drop, prop. On Day 5, the students read the following phrases: on the brim, in the crib, do not fret, grip, the bat, eat the crust, get a trim, a good crop, find the drum, grab the frog, some good grub, set a trap, on a trip, drop the bag, from the frost, get the crab, Fran and Brad. 

Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to encode words with taught phonics patterns. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 4, Day 3, students use the Sound-Spelling Mapping routine to encode the words got, job, bit, hop, pot, and an. Students finger-stretch the dictated word and place a dot in a box in the Student Workbook for each sound, then move corresponding colored phonics chips into each box on their phonics mat. Students write the letters in the boxes in the workbook and then whisper-read the word. 

  • In Lesson 25, Day 1, students use the Sound-Spelling Mapping Routine to encode the words thin, shrink, clang, bonk, click, and strong. Students finger-stretch the dictated word and place a dot in a box in the Student Workbook for each sound, using a larger box for phonograms. Students write the letters in the boxes, then underline the phonogram pattern or mark a v connecting the vowels in silent -e words. Students whisper the phonogram or vowel sound and read the word. 

Student-guided practice and independent practice of blending sounds using the sound-spelling pattern(s) is not varied and frequent. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 1, Day 4, students listen to a dedicated series of letters, then say the sounds while recording the letters in the Student Workbook. Then, students blend the sounds to read the word. Words include hen, hot, get, can, box, den, set, pet, tin. 

Materials provide opportunities for students to engage in word-level decoding practice focused on accuracy and automaticity. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 13, Day 4, students complete the following four dictated word chains, identifying which sound and letter change to make each new word: dish/wish/with/wick, flesh/fleck/flock/flop, math/mash/smash/smack, tick/tock/mock/moth

  • In Lesson 24, Day 3, the phonograms -all, -oll, and -alk are introduced. Students practice word reading accuracy using the following list of words: ball, talk, stroll, spend, walk, stink, chip, fame, balk, brave, stall, roll, poll, malls, wall, troll, stalk, small, fall, and strive. 

  • In Lesson 27, Day 5, students chorally read the words draw, fail, toy, coin, play, brain, spray, and fault. Then, students complete a one-minute timed reading from a list of 16 words containing the vowel team patterns ai, ay, oi, oy, au, and aw.

Indicator 1L
04/04

Spelling rules and generalizations are taught one at a time at a reasonable pace. Spelling words and generalizations are practiced to automaticity.

The materials include spelling rules and generalizations aligned to the phonics scope and sequence. The materials contain explanations for spelling of specific words or spelling rules. The materials provide the teacher with scripting for explaining phonics patterns repeatedly throughout the week with instructional routines. The materials contain sufficient opportunities for students to practice spelling rules and generalizations. Activities for students to practice spelling rules and generalizations occur throughout the week. Activities include Sound-Spelling Mapping, Writing Pattern and Contrast Words, Underlining Pattern Words, and Writing Dictated Sentences.

Spelling rules and generalizations are aligned to the phonics scope and sequence. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 8, Day 2, the Scope and Sequence indicates a phonics focus on  initial and final s-blends. The teacher models spelling the words spot and list.

  • In Lesson 17, Day 2, the Scope and Sequence indicates a phonics focus on silent-e pattern words. The teacher models spelling the words ripe, glide, smug, stride, slide, damp, and wide.

  • In Lesson 19, Day 1, the Scope and Sequence indicates a phonics focus on the long o silent -e syllable pattern. The teacher models spelling the words zone, bone, drove, flash, probe, chase, and froze.

Materials include explanations for spelling of specific words or spelling rules. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 9, Day 1, the teacher tells students about consonant blends. The teacher says, “An l- or t- blend has 2 consonants side by side. Each consonant in a blend is pronounced. The l- or t- blend can be in the initial or final position in a word. The word initial means at the beginning…the word final means at the end.”

  • In Lesson 14, Day 1, the teacher introduces the Floss Rule pattern and displays a slide stating the rule with example words puff, pull, mess, and fuzz. The teacher asks students to repeat the sentence, “The letters f, l, s, and z are doubled at the end of a word after a short vowel. The doubled consonant is pronounced as one sound.”

  • In Lesson 26, Day 1, the materials include a note that explains the -igh spelling pattern: “The letters g and h become part of a vowel team when they follow the single vowel letter i. When these 3 letters ‘team up,’ they are pronounced with 1 sound /i/.”

Students have sufficient opportunities to practice spelling rules and generalizations. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 21, Day 1, students spell the words slide, cake, ship, twine, globe, and grass using the Sound-Spelling Mapping routine. When a word contains a silent -e pattern, students record a small e in the corner of the final sound box and connect that e to the long vowel using a v-shape. 

  • In Lesson 28, Day 3, after learning the sounds of vowel team ow, ea, and ee, students spell the following words: throw, flow, sea, ship, head, frow, and camp.

Indicator 1M
04/04

Materials include decodable texts with phonics aligned to the program’s scope and sequence and opportunities for students to use decodables for multiple readings.

The materials provide decodable texts containing grade-level phonics skills aligned to the program’s scope and sequence. The materials include detailed lesson plans for repeated readings of decodable texts to address acquisition of phonics skills. Reading practice occurs in decodable texts until students can accurately decode single-syllable and multisyllabic words. Materials also include 20 Decodable Duos readers and an alignment document that indicates the focus skill and corresponding lesson number. 

Decodable texts contain grade-level phonics skills aligned to the program’s scope and sequence. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 5, students read the story Ned and Meg at the Vet. The story contains words such as beg, get, Jen, led, Meg, Ned, pen, pet, vet, yes, and yet, which align to the phonics skill of the lesson, short e. 

  • In Lesson 9, students read the story The Raft Club. The story includes words such as glad, twin, plums, and raft, which align to the phonics skill of the lesson, initial and final l- and t- blends. 

  • In Lesson 15, students read the story The Next Plan. The story contains words such as bench, chest, dash, rush, shin, smash, path, that, them, then, this, thump, with, when, which align to the phonics skill of consonant digraphs (ch, sh, th, wh). 

Materials include detailed lesson plans for repeated readings of decodable texts to address acquisition of phonics skills. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 4, Day 5, students choose to reread one of two passages previously read in their workbook earlier in the week. Both passages, My Funny Dog Bob and The Job of a Top Cop, have words such as mom, fog, log, and sod that align with the phonics skill of the week: short vowel o.

  • In Lesson 7, the materials provide instructions for rereading two passages. On Day 1, students underline pattern words while reading the passage as the teacher follows the script. On Day 2, the teacher tells students to whisper read the passage Gus and Peg and to think about the beginning, middle, and end of the passage. On Day 3, the teacher introduces a new passage about a canyon and guides students to underline pattern words. On Day 4,  the teacher tells students it is time to read the passage The Canyon and gives the following instructions: “First, we will read the passage aloud together. While we’re reading, think about the main topic of the passage. (Guide students in chorally reading the passage starting with the title).” On Day 5, the teacher is provided with instruction stating, “Today, you are going to practice reading 1 of the passages. One was about a kid and 2 cats. The second was about a visit to a big canyon. Passage 1 is on page 44 and passage 2 is on page 47.”

  • In Lesson 17, Day 5,  students reread both passages previously read in their workbook earlier in the week. Both passages, Mike the Mime and Bike and Hike and Dive have words such as side, ride, nine, and five that align with the phonics skill of the week, long vowel silent - e, long i.

Reading practice occurs in decodable texts (i.e., an absence of predictable) until students can accurately decode single syllable and multisyllabic words. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 3, students read the passage The Tip for a Big Hit featuring short vowel i words such as big, did, dig, fit, hit, in, is, it, Jim, kid, Kim, pit, Sid, Sis, tip, win.

  • In Lesson 9, students read the passage The Raft Club featuring decodable words with initial and final l- and t- blends such as blast, clam, clan, clip, club, glad, plan, plum, slim, slip, gulp, held, help, step, stop, trap, trip, twin, blast, cast, fast, just, last, lift, list, must, past, raft, rest, rift, vest, went.

  • In Lesson 20, students read the passages Luke the Rude Brute or Playing the Flute, which have words aligned to the lesson’s phonics skill of long vowel silent -e, long u such as in dude, cute, tunes, and mute.

Indicator 1N
02/04

Materials regularly and systematically offer assessment opportunities that measure student progress of phonics in- and out-of-context (as indicated by the program scope and sequence).

The materials provide a limited variety of assessment opportunities over the year to demonstrate students’ progress toward mastery and independence in phonics. Summative unit assessments are the only form of assessment utilized with all students as the Phonics Screener for Intervention (PSI) is optional. The materials also provide spelling tests on the last page of every lesson, but those are optional. Materials lack formative assessments and progress monitoring. Assessment materials provide teachers and students with information concerning students’ current skills/level of understanding of phonics. However, materials provide teachers with limited instructional suggestions for assessment-based steps to help students progress toward mastery of phonics.

Materials provide a limited variety of assessment opportunities over the course of the year to demonstrate students’ progress toward mastery and independence in phonics. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • According to the Scope and Sequence/Assessment Overview, Summative Unit Assessments take place at the end of each of the five units based on the learning from that unit after a week of review. Each unit spans four to seven weeks. 

    • Lessons 1-7: Assessment 1: Review of Kindergarten skills and closed Syllables

    • Lessons 8-15: Assessment 2: Consonant blends and digraphs

    • Lessons 16-21: Assessment 3: Long vowel sIlent -e syllables, and open syllables

    • Lessons 22-25: Assessment 4: Phonograms

    • Lessons 26-30: Assessment 5: Introduction to Grade 2 skills and multi-syllable words

  • In the Phonics Screener for Intervention User Manual, the materials state, “The PSI can be given as soon as a need for increased accuracy in reading is identified.” This assessment assesses using both real and nonsense words in the areas of basic phonics skills (short vowels such as VC and CVC, short vowels with consonant blends, short vowels with consonant digraphs, and long vowels spelled with the silent-e pattern), advanced phonics skills (vowel teams including predictable and unpredictable, vowel-r, and complex consonants), six syllable types, and sight words. Form A is used for the initial assessment and Forms B and C are available for retesting to determine whether a student has mastered the skill.

Assessment materials provide teachers and students with information concerning students’ current skills/level of understanding of phonics. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Assessment Overview, Summative Unit Assessments, the materials state, “The summative assessment is used to determine if students have mastered the critical skills within the unit lessons. If a student misses more than 1 response in a section, check the student’s understanding of the skill with additional items that are similar to those in the assessment.”

  • In the Assessment Overview, Summative Unit Assessments, the materials state that “If at least 80% of the students in the class respond correctly to each section, it is an indication that core instruction is sufficient for acquiring critical reading skills. If less than 80% are responding correctly, additional teaching of the specific skill is recommended.” 

  • In the Phonics Screener for Intervention User Manual, the materials state that the purpose is to identify which skills a student has mastered (90% or greater) and which ones he or she is missing (below 90%) using the analysis worksheet. A student’s performance on this sequence of skills provides information about where to begin intervention instruction. 

Materials support teachers with limited instructional suggestions for assessment-based steps to help students to progress toward mastery in phonics. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Assessment Overview, the materials state: “If less than 80% [of the students in the class] are responding correctly, additional teaching of the specific skill is recommended during Tier 1 core instruction either as a whole group or in a differentiated small group.” The materials do not provide guidance on that instruction. 

  • In the Assessment Overview, the materials state that if a student does not have mastery of the skill, the student “may require additional practice opportunities, re-teaching, or additional time to master the skill(s), but the materials do not support the teacher with instructional suggestions. 

  • In the Phonics Screener for Intervention User Manual, the materials state that by analyzing the data on the analysis worksheets, the teacher can focus instruction on the specific needs of the struggling reader. Instruction can be focused and explicit for skills that were not previously learned. The teacher groups students based on any skill the student scored below 90% on to provide focused, direct, and explicit instruction in the needed skill area.

Criterion 1.3: Word Recognition and Word Analysis

09/12

Materials and instruction support students in learning and practicing regularly and irregularly spelled high-frequency words.

The materials offer some systematic and explicit instruction of high-frequency words through teacher scripting and sound-spelling mapping routines, but the approach is inconsistent. While teacher modeling connects phonemes to graphemes for some words, other instances simply provide word lists for students to read without instruction. The program introduces only 41 high-frequency words throughout the year, which is insufficient to support significant reading progress. Students practice decoding these words in isolation using word grids and in context through decodable passages and Decodable Duo readers, though these tasks are not always explicitly tied to the lesson’s high-frequency words. Encoding opportunities similarly include previously taught high-frequency words but are not consistently aligned with lesson-specific targets.

In contrast, the materials provide frequent and varied instruction in syllabication and morpheme analysis, with routines such as syllable type gestures, word sorts, and explicit instruction in inflectional endings. Assessment opportunities include five unit assessments, four of which require syllable analysis, encoding multisyllabic words, and syllable division. While passage reading assessments include some high-frequency words, word recognition is not directly evaluated. Although general guidance is provided for reteaching based on assessment data, resources and strategies for next instructional steps are minimal.

Indicator 1O
01/02

Materials include explicit instruction in identifying the regularly spelled part and the temporarily irregularly spelled part of words. High-frequency word instruction includes spiraling review.

Materials include some systematic and explicit instruction of high-frequency words with an explicit and consistent instructional routine through teacher scripting of sound spelling mapping of heart and high-frequency words. For some high-frequency words, students are given a list of words and the students read them with no instruction. Other times in the program, materials include teacher modeling of the spelling and reading of high-frequency words that include connecting the phonemes to the graphemes. The materials do not include a sufficient amount of high-frequency words to make sufficient reading progress, with only 41 words throughout the year. 

Materials include some systematic and explicit instruction of high-frequency words with an explicit and consistent instructional routine. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 4,  Day 4, the teacher displays a high-frequency word grid containing 16 words, of which the first two are as and then. The teacher prompts students to read each word by saying, “Word?” at each box. There is no direct instruction when the teacher introduces the high-frequency words. 

  • In Lesson 8, Day 5, the teacher displays the word over using the digital display and says the first word is over. The teacher then finger stretches the word /ō/ /v/ /er/ and asks the students how many sounds. The teacher then writes the word under the column labeled “3 sounds.” The teacher says the sounds aloud and writes the letters, then reads the word over. 

  • In Lesson 18, Day 5, the teacher introduces the word again using sound spelling mapping. The teacher explains that the word does not fit the patterns they have learned. The teacher says the word again, and finger stretches the word /ŭ/ /g/ /ĕ/ /n/. The teacher asks how many sounds are in the word and then places a dot in the bottom right corner of 4 boxes. The teacher writes the letter or letters that represent each sound by asking the students what each sound is and telling them the letter or letters she will write. For unexpected spellings, such as the a and ai in again, the teacher draws a heart in the box to indicate the unexpected spelling.

  • In Lesson 19, Day 4, the teacher displays a high-frequency word grid containing 16 words. The first two words are stop and fly, which are the high-frequency words for the week. The teacher prompts students to read each word by saying, “Word?” at each box.

Materials include teacher modeling of the spelling and reading of high-frequency words that includes connecting the phonemes to the graphemes. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 10, Day 5, the teacher models finger stretching the word from /f//r//ŭ//m/ and asks how many sounds there are. Students say the sounds as the teacher writes the letters and reads the word. The teacher writes the word from on the chart under the heading “4 sounds.” The chart has the headings: “2 sounds,” “3 sounds,” and “4 sounds.”

  • In Lesson 22, Day 5, the teacher finger stretches the word once /w//ŭ//n//s/ and asks how many sounds. The students say the sounds as the teacher writes the letters and then reads the word. The teacher writes the word once on the chart under the heading “4 sounds.”

  • In Lesson 27, Day 5, the teacher models using the Sound-Spelling Mapping routine to spell the word they. The teacher says the word and asks students to finger-stretch it into its sounds. The teacher places a dot in the corner of two of the sound-spelling boxes and records th in the first box. Students identify the second sound /ā/. The teacher tells students that the /ā/ sound in this word is spelled e-y. The teacher records ey in the second box and places a heart above the letters, telling students that the heart represents an unexpected spelling. 

Materials do not include a sufficient quantity of high-frequency words for students to make reading progress. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • According to the Scope and Sequence, the materials introduce 41 high-frequency words over the course of Lessons 1-24. Lessons 26-30 include an introduction to six second-grade high-frequency words. Lessons 7, 15, 21, and 25 include a review of previously taught high-frequency words.

Indicator 1P
02/02

Instructional opportunities are frequently built into the materials for students to practice and gain decoding automaticity of high-frequency words.

Students practice decoding high-frequency words in isolation through the use of four-by-four-word grids. Lessons provide students with opportunities to decode high-frequency words in context in the decodable passages and Decodable Duo readers; however, practice is not always explicitly tied to the lesson’s high-frequency words in which the decoding tasks appear. Lessons include opportunities to encode high-frequency words in tasks, but practice is not always explicitly tied to the lesson’s high-frequency words in which the encoding tasks appear. The encoding tasks and decodable texts include some previously taught high-frequency words.

Students practice decoding high-frequency words in isolation. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 6, Day 4, students chorally read 16 high-frequency words from a word grid. The teacher times students for one minute as they read the words independently. At the end of one minute, students circle the last word they read. Words include were, them, could, when, as, then, had, some, little, under, went, well, yellow, all, brown, and soon.  

  • In Lesson 8, Day 5, students finger stretch the high-frequency words, decide the number of sounds in the word, and then record the word under the appropriate column indicating if the word has two, three, or four sounds. Students say the sounds aloud as they record the letters and then state the word. The list of high-frequency words includes of, jump, as, had, please, an, and him.

  • In Lesson 17, Day 4, students chorally read 16 high-frequency words from a word grid. The teacher times students for one minute as they independently read the words after, how, every, could, want, by, walk, think, here, our, let, who, there, going any, and over. At the end of one minute, the students circle the last word they read.  

Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to decode high-frequency words in context. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 4, Day 1, students read the passage “My Funny Dog Bob.” The passage contains the high-frequency words my, funny, he, too, she, little, play, with, the, under, see, of, to, good, look, finds, want, and likes.

  • In Lesson 9, Day 1, students read the passage “The Frog Trap.” The passage contains the high-frequency words the, are, to, you, make, here, of then, will, like, want, and see.

  • In Lesson 16, Day 2, students read the passage “The Lake Raft.” The passage contains the previously introduced high-frequency words her, him, had, as, and then

  • In Lesson 21, the materials include the Decodable Duo reader Jude’s June Hike for small-group instruction. The Words to Know Chart highlights the high-frequency words out, of, the, was, to, she, see, her, and said included in the text. The materials introduce the word her in Lesson 2. The words out, the, to, she, see, was, and said are included in the Kindergarten Scope and Sequence. 

Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to encode high-frequency words in tasks, such as sentences, in order to promote automaticity of high-frequency words. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 8, Day 5, students write dictated sentences in their workbook, including Spot was too fast for her. The sun can be a risk to the skin. I saw a black spot under my skin. Although not directly stated, the high-frequency word her is included in the sentences students write.

  • In Lesson 18, Day 5, students write dictated sentences in their workbook, including Steve and Zeke go to Lake Meke again. These grebes are fun to see. The theme made me smile. Although not directly stated, the high-frequency word again is included in the sentences students write.

  • In Lesson 22, Day 5, students write the sentences, The strong stink is from the sink, The king was flinging his bling, and The gang sang a funny song. The sentences contain the high-frequency words the, from, was, a, and funny. The high-frequency word from is listed in the Grade 1 Scope and Sequence. The high-frequency words the, was, a, and funny are listed in the Kindergarten Scope and Sequence.

  • In Lesson 24, Day 5, students write the sentences, We have slate stones to make the wall tall, It was fun rolling in the grass, and The chalk makes dust on the wall. The sentences contain the high-frequency words the and was. While these high-frequency words are not included in the scope and sequence, student practice spelling the and was in isolation during a Sound-Spelling Mapping activity in Lesson 12.

Indicator 1Q
04/04

Materials include explicit instruction in syllabication and morpheme analysis and provide students with practice opportunities to apply learning.

The materials include frequent and varied instruction and practice in syllabication and morpheme analysis. The materials use recurring instructional and practice routines that include but are not limited to syllable type gestures, repeated identification of syllable type and vowel sound, Sound-Spelling Mapping with syllable symbols, and word sorts. The materials also include explicit instruction in morpheme analysis, specifically inflectional endings.

Materials contain frequent explicit instruction of syllable types and routines for syllable division that promote decoding and encoding of words. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 2, Day 1, the teacher defines vowels, consonants, and syllables. The teacher tells students that all syllables have at least one vowel sound and that there are six syllable types. The teacher introduces a closed syllable and tells students that closed syllables have one vowel letter followed by one or more consonants, and the vowel sound is short. The teacher shows students the gesture for a closed syllable, which is a closed fist. Students repeat the definition of a closed syllable. 

  • In Lesson 4, Day 1, the teacher explains that closed syllables have one vowel. The teacher models the routine for identifying closed syllables with short vowel sounds. The routine is: 

    • “1. Find the vowel

    • 2. Determine if there is a vowel followed by a consonant

    • 3. Make the short vowel sound

    • 4. Do the short vowel gesture

    • 5. Sort the word under the proper short vowel column.”

  • In Lesson 20, Day 1, the teacher explains that vowel consonant-e syllables have one vowel with a single consonant and a silent e at the end. The teacher then models the routine for identifying vowel consonant-e syllables with long vowel sounds. The routine is: 

    • “1. Find the vowel 

    • 2. Determine if there is a vowel followed by a consonant with a silent e at the end

    • 3. Make the long vowel sound

    • 4. Do the long vowel gesture 

    • 5. Sort the word under the proper long vowel column.”

Materials contain frequent explicit instruction in morpheme analysis to decode unfamiliar words. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 7, Day 4, the teacher displays the rule table for adding -ed to a verb. The table contains the examples fish/fished, bake/baked, and tap/tapped. The teacher explains spelling rules for words spelled with a vowel team, y, or two or more consonants at the end of a word, words with the silent -e patten, and words spelled with one vowel and one consonant. The teacher displays the word fit. The teacher identifies the word type and tells students that because fit has one vowel followed by one consonant, we use the third rule from the table to add an ending. The teacher tells students the new word is fitted and writes the word in a table with columns for Base Word and New Word +ed.

  • In Lesson 15, Day 4, the teacher models how to use the inflectional endings -er and -est. The teacher explains there are three rules for writing and reading these inflectional endings. The rules are: 

    • “1. For words spelled with two or more consonants at the end, add -er or -est

    • 2. For words spelled with y at the end, drop the last y and add i before adding -er or -est

    • 3. For words spelled with a single vowel followed by one consonant, double the final consonant before adding -er or -est

    The teacher models the following routine for students: “Read the base word. Check for the number of consonants or the letter y after the vowel. Decide which rule to use. Write the base word plus the -er and -est using the correct spelling rule. Read the word.” 

  • In Lesson 21, Day 2, the teacher displays the rule table for adding -ing, -s/-es, and -ed to a verb. The table explains spelling rules for words spelled with a vowel team, y, or two or more consonants at the end of a word, words with the silent -e pattern, and words spelled with one vowel and one consonant. The teacher reads each spelling rule, and then students repeat the rule. The teacher displays the word dress. The teacher identifies the syllable type and tells students that because dress has two consonants at the end, we use the first rule from the table to add an ending. The teacher writes the verbs dresses, dressed, and dressing in a table under the correct verb ending column heading. 

Multiple and varied opportunities are provided over the course of the year for students to learn, practice, and apply word analysis strategies. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Lesson 4, Day 3, students scan the decodable passageThe Job of a Top Cop” with the teacher. When students see a word with the short o pattern, they hold up the closed syllable gesture. 

  • In Lesson 17, Day 4, in the word chains section, students practice analyzing words and applying the vowel consonant-e syllable type to the following closed syllable words to make new words: slid to slide and slim to slime. 

  • In Lesson 20, Day 2, students use the Sound-Spelling Mapping routine to spell the words dupe, tub, five, tone, rule, and duke. Students use a v shape to connect the silent e to the vowel if the word follows the silent e pattern. Students whisper the syllable type and read the word.

Indicator 1R
02/04

Materials regularly and systematically offer assessment opportunities that measure student progress of word recognition and analysis (as indicated by the program scope and sequence).

The materials include assessment opportunities in the area of word analysis. The materials include five unit assessments. Four assessments include items in which students analyze syllable types, encode multisyllabic words by syllable, and perform syllable division. Assessments include passage reading in which the passages contain some high-frequency words, but word recognition is not directly assessed. The materials include general information about when reteaching or further assessment is necessary based on assessment data but do not provide guidance or resources for instructional next steps. 

Materials regularly and systematically provide a variety of assessment opportunities over the course of the year to demonstrate students’ progress toward mastery and independence of word recognition and analysis. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In the End of Unit Assessment, Unit 3, students sort the following words by syllable type: pride, grass, zone, theme, shin. Students are awarded one point for correct spelling and one point for sorting the word into the correct group. 

  • In the End of Unit Assessment, Unit 4, students spell the dictated words table, rustic, and sunset in a chart, recording the first syllable, second syllable, and whole word. Students are awarded one point for each correctly spelled syllable and one point for the correctly spelled word. Points are not awarded for incorrectly divided syllables. 

  • In the End of Unit Assessment, Unit 5, students sort the syllables in the words campus, jumbo, escape, and dentist. Students underline the vowels, draw a syllable division line, and record the syllables in the correct column. Columns include Closed, Long Vowel Silent -e, or Open. Students are awarded one point for underlining the vowels, one point for dividing the syllables, and one point for each syllable correctly sorted.

Assessment materials provide the teacher and students with limited information concerning students’ current skills/level of understanding of word recognition and word analysis. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Assessment Overview, the materials indicate that if a student misses more than one response in a section, the teacher should “check the student’s understanding of the skill with additional items that are similar to those in the assessment. Students who do not have full understanding of the skill(s) may require additional practice opportunities, re-teaching or additional time to master the skill(s).” 

Materials support the teacher with limited instructional suggestions for assessment-based steps to help students to progress toward mastery in word recognition and word analysis. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In the Assessment Overview, the materials indicate that if less than 80% of students respond correctly to an individual assessment section, the teacher should provide additional teaching of the specific skill assessed during Tier 1 instruction.

Criterion 1.4: Fluency

08/12

Materials provide systematic and explicit instruction and practice in fluency by mid-to-late 1st and 2nd grade. Materials for 2nd grade fluency practice should vary (decodables and grade-level texts).

The materials lack explicit and systematic instruction in oral reading fluency, offering limited support to develop accuracy, automaticity, and prosody. Although the materials include two decodable passages per week and 20 Decodable Duos readers, fluency instruction is largely limited to scanning passages for target phonics patterns and repeated readings. While the materials suggest modeling fluent reading and provide a Fluency Pack with best practices, opportunities for students to hear fluent reading of grade-level text are sparse. Lessons follow a recurring routine of identifying, reading, and rereading phonics-focused passages across five days, but these activities do not sufficiently address broader fluency skills. Corrective feedback guidance is included but is limited to word reading in isolation or within texts. Assessment tools for fluency are minimal, with general guidelines for progress monitoring and a student tracking chart. While the materials reference universal screeners, they do not provide one, relying instead on external resources. The provided progress monitoring lacks specificity and offers limited instructional adjustments to address individual student needs.

Indicator 1S
02/04

Instructional opportunities are built into the materials for systematic, evidence-based, explicit instruction in oral reading fluency.

The materials lack explicit, systematic instruction in oral reading fluency. The materials include two decodable passages per week. The teacher reads through the words containing the week’s target phonics pattern with students, but this is the only instructional support to promote accuracy and automaticity in decodable text. The materials include a Fluency Pack that outlines best practices in fluency instruction. While this document details the importance of modeling fluent reading and offers suggestions for how to model fluent reading, the lessons lack opportunities for students to hear fluent reading of grade-level text. The materials also include a set of 20 Decodable Duos readers. The recommended routine for using these readers includes suggested modeling of fluent reading.

Materials do not include opportunities for explicit, systematic instruction in automaticity, accuracy, and prosody using grade-level decodable connected text (e.g. decodable texts, poetry, readers’ theater, paired reading). Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • Before decodable texts students chorally read a list of phonetically regular words, but there is no explicit instruction in automaticity, accuracy, and prosody. 

Materials provide opportunities for students to hear fluent reading of grade-level text by a model reader. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Decodable Duos Set 1-A, Recommended Routine, the materials provide ideas for using the Decodable Duos in small-group instruction, including reading the text aloud to model fluent reading. 

Materials include a variety of resources for explicit instruction in oral reading fluency. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Ancillary Materials, Fluency Resources, the materials include a Fluency Pack. The Fluency Pack contains the document, “Best Practices for Teaching Fluency,” and 26 fluency passages aligned to the phonics scope and sequence.  

  • In Decodable Duos Set 1-A, Recommended Routine, the materials provide ideas for using the Decodable Duos in small-group instruction, including reading the text aloud to model fluent reading and chorally reading the text with students.

Indicator 1T
04/04

Varied and frequent opportunities are built into the materials for students to engage in supported practice to gain automaticity and prosody beginning in mid-Grade 1 and through Grade 2 (once accuracy is secure).

The materials include opportunities for repeated readings of decodable passages. Lessons include two decodable passages each week. The recurring passage reading routine includes students scanning the passage to identify words with the lesson’s phonics target on Days 1 and 3, then reading the underlined words, followed by reading the passage as a whole on Days 2 and 4, and then rereading both passages on Day 5 to promote automaticity. The materials include a Fluency Pack with additional passages. The materials indicate that teachers should provide corrective feedback in order to promote fluency, and provide some guidance for corrective feedback about word reading in isolation and in text.

Varied, frequent opportunities are provided over the course of the year for students to gain automaticity and prosody. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following: 

  • In Lesson 6, Day 4, students whisper read the underlined words containing short vowel u words in the passage “Gus and Liz.” Then, they go back and whisper read the entire passage. 

  • In Lesson 9, Day 4, students whisper read the underlined words containing initial and final l- and t-blends in the passage “Kids of the Past.” Then, they go back and whisper read the entire passage. 

  • In Lesson 16, Day 2, students whisper read the underlined words containing long a silent -e words in the passage “Bake Sales.” Then students go back and whisper read the entire passage. 

  • In Lesson 18, Day 2, students whisper read the underlined words containing long vowel silent-e and long e in the passage “The Grebes of Lake Meke.” Then students go back and whisper read the entire passage. 

Materials provide practice opportunities for oral reading fluency in a variety of settings (e.g., repeated readings, diad or partner reading, continuous reading). Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Lesson 7, Day 5, students reread the week’s two passages, “Gus and Peg” and “The Canyon.” 

  • In Lesson 10, Day 5, students reread the week’s two passages, “Brad Can Brag” and “A Trap for a Frog.” 

  • In Lesson 21, Day 5, students reread the week’s two passages, “Jude’s June Hike” and “Drones.” 

  • In Lesson 26, Day 5, students reread the week’s two passages, “Doe the Goat and Kids” and “Keep Loads of Luck.” 

Materials include guidance and corrective feedback suggestions to the teacher for supporting students’ gains in oral reading fluency. Examples include, but are not limited to the following: 

  • In Decodable Duos Set 1-A, Recommended Routine, the materials indicate that teachers may listen as students whisper read the text, providing corrective feedback when appropriate. 

  • In the Ancillary materials, Teacher Information, the Corrective Feedback for Positive Achievement document provides examples for the teacher on how to provide corrective feedback on wording reading in isolation and in text.

Indicator 1U
02/04

Materials regularly and systematically offer assessment opportunities that measure student progress in oral reading fluency (as indicated by the program scope and sequence).

The materials provide limited fluency assessment materials. The materials outline a procedure for fluency progress monitoring and provide a student tracking chart. The materials reference use of a universal screener, but a screener is not provided. Instead, the materials include a list of commonly used universal screeners. The progress monitoring guidelines are general and provide limited support for determining students’ current levels. The materials provide minimal instructional adjustments to support continued growth in fluency. 

Multiple assessment opportunities are not provided regularly and systematically over the course of the year for students to demonstrate progress toward mastery and independence of oral reading fluency. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Fluency Pack, Best Practices for Teaching Fluency, the materials provide a list of commonly used universal fluency screeners. The materials indicate that universal screeners are used by most school districts and are generally administered 1-3 times per year. 

  • In the Fluency Pack, the materials indicate that the teacher should monitor student fluency progress using the Words Correct Per Minute (WCPM) measure. To measure this, the materials explain that the teacher should give a student a text to read that is written at their instructional level. The student gets one minute to read the text to the teacher. While the student is reading, the teacher marks each word the student reads incorrectly. A formula for determining WCPM is not given in the materials. 

Assessment materials provide the teacher and students with limited information about students’ current skills/level of understanding of oral reading fluency. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Fluency Pack, Best Practices for Teaching Fluency, the materials indicate that teachers should engage in progress monitoring for beginning readers using a fluency word list until students achieve a threshold word correct per minute score (threshold score not specified in materials). After this point, the materials indicate that students should shift to using a passage at their instructional level, which may be lower than their grade level. The materials indicate that an appropriate passage is one in which students make errors on no more than one in ten words. 

  • In the Fluency Pack, Best Practices for Teaching Fluency, the materials provide fluency tracking forms and outline the procedure for their use. The materials indicate that teachers should identify each student’s current reading level, determine a reading level for each student to achieve by the end of the year, set a timeframe for achieving the goal, and create an aim line on the fluency tracking chart. The materials indicate that if a student is reading below grade level, the teacher should make the timeframe half of what it would be for an on-level student, with the goal of accelerating progress. 

  • In the Fluency Pack, Best Practices for Teaching Fluency, it states that after a fluency assessment is administered, the teacher should graph a student’s data and make it readily available to all who work with the student. It also suggests that the teacher should consider having all students keep graphs of their own WCPM scores, as tracking their own progress increases students’ motivation and investment in their reading goals. 

Materials minimally support the teacher with instructional adjustments to help students make progress toward mastery in oral reading fluency. Examples include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In the Fluency Pack, Best Practices for Teaching Fluency, the materials indicate that if three consecutive data points fall below the aim line, the education team should meet to determine whether to modify the student’s instruction. The materials indicate that if the team determines modifications are necessary, the teacher should increase the intensity of instruction and the frequency of progress monitoring. 

  • In the Fluency Pack, the materials explain that if a student’s performance improves, then the intensity of instruction and frequency of monitoring can be reduced.

Criterion 2.1: Guidance for Implementation

NE = Not Eligible. Product did not meet the threshold for review.
NE

Materials are accompanied by information that provides the teacher with guidance for implementation of daily lessons and information to enhance teacher knowledge of foundational skills.

Indicator 2A
00/04

Materials provide teacher guidance with useful annotations and suggestions for how to enact the student materials and ancillary materials to support students' literacy development.

Indicator 2B
00/04

Materials contain full, adult-level explanations and examples of the foundational skills concepts included in the program so teachers can improve their own knowledge of the subject, as necessary.

Indicator 2C
00/04

Foundational skills lessons are well-designed and take into account effective lesson structure and pacing. Content can reasonably be completed within a regular school year, and the pacing allows for maximum student understanding.

Indicator 2D
00/02

Materials include publisher-produced alignment documentation of the standards addressed by specific questions, tasks, and assessments and assessment materials clearly denote which standards are being emphasized.

Indicator 2E
Read

Materials contain strategies for informing all stakeholders, including students, parents, or caregivers about the foundational skills program and suggestions for how they can help support student progress and achievement.

Criterion 2.2: Student Supports

NE = Not Eligible. Product did not meet the threshold for review.
NE

The program includes materials designed for each child’s regular and active participation in grade-level/grade-band/series content.

Indicator 2F
00/04

Materials provide strategies and supports for students who read, write, and/or speak in a language other than English to meet or exceed grade-level standards to regularly participate in learning English language arts and literacy.

Indicator 2G
00/04

Materials provide strategies and supports for students in special populations to work with grade-level content and to meet or exceed grade-level standards that will support their regular and active participation in learning English language arts and literacy.

Indicator 2H
Read

Materials provide a balance of images or information about people, representing various demographic and physical characteristics.

Indicator 2I
Read

Materials provide guidance to encourage teachers to draw upon student home language to facilitate learning.

Criterion 2.3: Intentional Design

NE = Not Eligible. Product did not meet the threshold for review.
NE

The program includes a visual design that is engaging and references or integrates digital technology, when applicable, with guidance for teachers.

Indicator 2J
Read

Materials integrate technology such as interactive tools, virtual manipulatives/objects, and/or dynamic software in ways that engage students in the grade-level/series standards, when applicable.

Indicator 2K
Read

The visual design (whether in print or digital) is not distracting or chaotic, but supports students in engaging thoughtfully with the subject.

Indicator 2L
Read

Materials provide teacher guidance for the use of embedded technology to support and enhance student learning, when applicable.