High School - Gateway 1
Back to High School Overview
Note on review tool versions
See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.
- Our current review tool version is 2.0. Learn more
- Reports conducted using earlier review tools (v1.0 and v1.5) contain valuable insights but may not fully align with our current instructional priorities. Read our guide to using earlier reports and review tools
Loading navigation...
Focus & Coherence
Gateway 1 - Meets Expectations | 83% |
|---|---|
Criterion 1.1: Focus & Coherence | 15 / 18 |
Criterion 1.1: Focus & Coherence
Focus and Coherence: The instructional materials are coherent and consistent with "the high school standards that specify the mathematics which all students should study in order to be college and career ready" (p. 57 of CCSSM).
The instructional materials for the Walch Traditional Florida series meet expectations for focus and coherence. The instructional materials meet expectations for attending to the full intent of the mathematical content contained in the high school standards for all students; spending the majority of time on the CCSSM widely applicable as prerequisites for a range of college majors, postsecondary programs, and careers (WAPs); engaging students in mathematics at a level of sophistication appropriate to high school; making meaningful connections in a single course and throughout the series; and explicitly identifying and building on knowledge from Grades 6-8 to the High School Standards. The instructional materials partially meet expectations for attending to the full intent of the modeling process and allowing students to fully learn each standard.
Indicator 1a
The materials focus on the high school standards.*
Indicator 1a.i
The materials attend to the full intent of the mathematical content contained in the high school standards for all students.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series meet expectations for attending to the full intent of the mathematical content contained in the high school standards for all students. The instructional materials include few instances where all aspects of the standards are not addressed across the courses of the series.
The following are examples for which the materials attend to the full intent of the standard:
- N-CN.3.7: In Algebra 2, Lesson 1A.6, students recall the imaginary unit i and how it applies to the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra in Key Concepts and Instruction. In Scaffolded Practice and Guided Practice, students solve quadratic equations with complex solutions.
- A-REI.2.3: In Algebra 1, Lesson 1.10, students solve linear equations. Throughout the lesson, students solve equations with variables on the same side of the equal sign, variables on opposite sides of the equal sign, and use the distributive property. Students also solve equations with coefficients represented by letters as seen in Practice Problems 9 and 10.
- F-IF.3.9: In Algebra 1, Lesson 2A.12, students compare linear functions represented by tables, equations, and graphs. Students compare y-intercepts and rates of change of linear functions. In Lesson 2A.13, students compare rates of change and y-intercepts of exponential functions in multiple ways. In the Problem-Based Task of Lesson 2A.13, students compare two medical procedures used to measure how well a person’s kidneys are functioning. Students compare the initial value of each procedure, as well as the rate of decay to determine which has a faster rate of decay.
- F-LE.2.5: In Algebra 2, Lesson 3A.4, students investigate the exponential growth of a savings account. Students interpret the meaning of each term of the function in context to the problem. Throughout the lesson, students work with population growth, half-life of radioactive material, and cooling of liquids. Students identify the initial value and relate its meaning to its context. Students create and compare equations to model a savings account in the Problem-Based Task in Lesson 3A.5. Students identify domain constraints and the outstanding balance after t months.
- G-SRT.3.7: In Geometry, Lesson 2.11, students explore the relationship between the sine and cosine of complementary angles. Through the Warm-Up, Scaffolded Practice, and Guided Practice, students explore sine and cosine as complements. Students determine the best location for a garden, based on the amount of sunlight it will receive, in the Problem-Based Task in Lesson 2.11. Students apply sine, cosine, and the Pythagorean Theorem in 30-60-90 degree triangles to defend their findings.
- G-C.1.1: In Geometry, Lesson 5.1, students extend their knowledge of similarity of triangles to prove similarity of circles. In the Problem-Based Task of Lesson 5.1, students prove all circles are similar. Students identify circular objects in the classroom and apply relationships between the parts of the circle (circumference and diameter) to prove similarity.
- S-IC.1.1: In Algebra 2, Lesson 4.4, students explore if a number of possible samples exist even for a small population. In the Guided Practice, students examine variability in sampling and assess a set of data representing the frequency of the most requested songs over a six-year time period in the Problem-Based Task. Students choose a sample of three songs from the six years and compare the mean and standard deviation of the sample to that of the population.
The materials attend to some aspects, but not all, of the following standards:
- G-CO.4.12: In Geometry, Lesson 1B.9 (copying segments and angles), Lesson 1B.10 (bisecting segments and angles), and Lesson 1B.11 (constructing perpendicular and parallel lines), students make formal geometric constructions using a straightedge and compass. In Lesson 1B.9, the Introduction and Key Concepts references utilizing patty paper, but students do not use this tool throughout the lesson. Other tools or methods for creating formal geometric constructions are not referenced in the materials.
- G-MG.1.1: In the Introduction of Geometry, Lesson 3.3, there is an example of cutting a carrot in half, resulting in either a circle or oval, depending upon the type of cut. No other opportunities were found where the materials use geometric shapes, their measures, and their properties to describe objects.
Indicator 1a.ii
The materials attend to the full intent of the modeling process when applied to the modeling standards.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series partially meet expectations for attending to the full intent of the modeling process when applied to the modeling standards. The instructional materials do not use the full intent of the modeling process with many modeling standards across the series.
The following standards are not addressed with the modeling process as students do not formulate, validate, and revise their own conclusions. Each of these Problem-Based Tasks, labeled as modeling in the instructional materials, have a specific answer, and students do not formulate their own model or method of computations, revisions, and validations:
- N-Q.1.1,3: In Algebra 1, Lesson 1.6, students create and graph an equation in the context of the cost of a phone card. The problem contains a constraint on the number of minutes used. Students determine the slope and y-intercept in the context of the problem. Throughout the lesson, the teacher’s resources provide guiding questions for the students to formulate, compute, interpret, and validate their findings. Students formulate a model, but they do not use the model to compute nor do they interpret or validate their computations.
- A-SSE.1.1: In Algebra 1, Lesson 4.1, students write an algebraic expression representing the area of a triangular deck when given one piece of information, such as the base is ten meters less than the altitude. Students identify the terms, factors, and coefficients of the expression. Students discuss their plans for constructing the algebraic expression to represent the area of the deck, but there are not multiple approaches to this problem and the coaching questions guide students to one particular path of producing the expression. Students do not compute anything once they have created this expression, nor do they have to interpret or validate their results.
- F-IF.2.4: In Algebra 1, Lesson 5.2, students create a quadratic model to determine the path a basketball travels. They use a quadratic model to determine for what horizontal distances the height of the ball is increasing and decreasing. Students are prompted by the teacher in the implementation guide to compare the strategies and explanations they used. There is not an opportunity for students to develop their own model or to devise their own computational pathway.
- F-IF.3.7e: In Algebra 2, Lessons 3A.1 and 3A.8, students are presented with a problem involving average lengths of rescue attempts for boaters. The function, domain, and range are given. Students interpret the meaning of the domain and range for the function in context, but students do not validate their conclusions and make appropriate revisions.
- F-TF.2.5: In Algebra 2, Lesson 2.6, students analyze a sine function that represents a note played on a piano. Students find an equation for the function representing the note that is one octave higher than the original note. Students do not have the opportunity to formulate their own model.
- G-SRT.3.8: In Geometry, Lesson 2.13, students use the Pythagorean Theorem and trigonometric ratios to calculate the distance from the roof a building to a windowsill where firefighters will need to descend by rope to enter the building. Students are provided the height of the firefighter as well as the angle of elevation. Students do not formulate their own model.
- G-GPE.2.7: In Geometry, Lesson 4.4, students use coordinates representing the locations of the vertices of a rectangular shaped baseball field to calculate the amount of fencing needed to enclose the field and the area of the field. Students use the distance formula and do not have the opportunity to validate and reflect upon their solution.
- G-MG.1.3: In Geometry, Lesson 3.6, students apply area formulas, congruence postulates, and the Pythagorean Theorem in order to determine missing lengths of triangular-shaped panels of a solar sail that is part of the design of an experimental spacecraft. Although students formulate and compute, the problem has one solution path and one correct solution. Students are directed to solve for missing side lengths by applying area formulas and the Pythagorean Theorem.
There are a few modeling standards for which the materials attend to with the full modeling process. The implementation guide for the teacher provides guidance to support students’ validation and interpretation of their results in some of the standards. Examples of this include:
- A-CED.1.3: In Algebra 1, Lesson 1.12, students write a system of inequalities to compare the time it takes for one group of workers to make the blades of figure skates and hockey skates to another group making the boots for both types of skates. Students provide possible combinations of the number of figure skates and hockey skates given the constraints of the time it takes for both groups to complete their job. Students test various scenarios for feasibility.
- S-ID.1.4: In Algebra 2, Lesson 4.1, students compare the mean and standard deviation of two lemonade machines. They provide an argument to explain which machine, if either, is better than the other in terms of how consistently it dispenses sufficient amounts of lemonade.
Indicator 1b
The materials provide students with opportunities to work with all high school standards and do not distract students with prerequisite or additional topics.
Indicator 1b.i
The materials, when used as designed, allow students to spend the majority of their time on the content from CCSSM widely applicable as prerequisites for a range of college majors, postsecondary programs, and careers.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series, when used as designed, meet expectations for allowing students to spend the majority of their time on the CCSSM widely applicable as prerequisites (WAPs) for a range of college majors, postsecondary programs, and careers. Examples of how the materials allow students to spend the majority of their time on the WAPs include:
- In Algebra 1, Unit 2A, Lessons 7-9, students use appropriate vocabulary to describe functions. Students analyze a function in terms of its graph and the context of the situation the graph depicts. In Lesson 2A.8, students calculate the average rate of change and compare rates of change over specific intervals (F-IF.2.6, F-LE.1.1a).
- In Algebra 1, the pacing guide recommends 25 days for Unit 2B, and of those days, 20 address WAPs from A-REI, solving systems of equations and inequalities, and F-BF.1.1 and F-LE.1.1 on creating equations and distinguishing between linear and exponential functions.
- In Geometry, Unit 2, Lessons 5-9, students extend their knowledge of triangle similarity statements to include Side-Angle-Side (SAS) and Side-Side-Side (SSS). Students use these similarity statements to prove the Pythagorean Theorem (Lesson 2.5). Students work with triangles related to this example and expand on their understanding of similar triangles, specifically the relationship between angle bisectors and ratio segments. In Lesson 2.9, students build an understanding of ratios of lengths of sides within right triangles (G-SRT.2.4,5).
- In Geometry, Unit 1B, Lessons 3-6, students prove each of the theorems represented in G-CO.3.10. For example, students prove measures of interior angles of a triangle sum to 180°, base angles of isosceles triangles are congruent, the segment joining midpoints of two sides of a triangle is parallel to the third side, and half the length and the medians of a triangle meet at a point.
- In Algebra 2, the pacing guide recommends 27 days for unit 3A, and of those days, 18 address WAPs from F-IF (graphing trigonometric, exponential, and logarithmic graphs). Students also interpret and identify key features of these graphs.
- In Algebra 2, Lesson 3.9, students interpret the slope and intercept of a linear model in the context of data (S-ID.3.7).
Indicator 1b.ii
The materials, when used as designed, allow students to fully learn each standard.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series, when used as designed, partially meet expectations for letting students fully learn each standard. The instructional materials do not enable students to fully learn some of the standards. All of the non-plus standards that would not be fully learned by students are:
- N-RN.1.3: In Algebra 1, Lessons 5.1 and 5.7, students determine that the sum or product of two rational numbers is rational, the sum of a rational number and an irrational number is irrational, and the product of a nonzero rational number and an irrational number is irrational. Explanations for these are provided in the teacher’s resources, but students do not provide any of the explanations.
- N-CN.1.3: In Algebra 2, Lesson 1A.3, students find the conjugate of complex numbers but do not use the conjugate to find the moduli and the quotients of complex numbers.
- A-APR.3.4: The teacher’s resources provide aspects to proving identities, but students do not prove polynomial identities. In Algebra 2, Lesson 1A.10, Guided Practice 1, students “determine which identity is written in the same form as the given expression,” but do not prove it.
- A-REI.3.5: In Algebra 1, Lesson 2B.6, students solve systems of linear equations using substitution and elimination, but students do not validate the solutions. In the Guided Practice, the materials indicate the solution to a system of equations would be validated through graphing, but students do not practice proving that by replacing one equation by the sum of that equation and a multiple of the other produces a system with the same solutions.
- F-IF.3.7e: Students do not fully learn to use midline when graphing trigonometric functions. In Algebra 2, Lesson 3A.1, Guided Practice 7 refers to midlines.
- G-CO.1.2: In Geometry, Lesson 1A.2, Guided Practice and Scaffolded Practice, students use transformation functions to find new coordinates, but students do not use transparencies or software to discover transformations. There is also limited practice with stretches and dilations in this lesson.
- G-CO.1.4: In Geometry, Lesson 1A.4, students have limited opportunities to use parallel lines, perpendicular lines, and circles to define transformations.
- G-CO.2.7: In Geometry, Lesson 1B.1, Problem-Based Task, students use congruences and geometric properties to determine congruent triangles within a figure, and students also identify congruent triangles according to congruent parts. Students do not use rigid motions to determine that triangles are congruent.
- G-CO.2.8: In Geometry, Lesson 1B.2, students work with triangle congruences to determine why two triangles are congruent, but rigid motions are not used to explain the triangle congruences.
- G-SRT.1.1a: No evidence was found where students use dilations with parallel lines.
- G-C.1.1: In Geometry, Lesson 5.1, Guided Practice, the materials use similarity transformations to prove that all circles are similar, but students do not practice this standard.
- G-GPE.1.2: In Geometry, Lesson 4.5, the materials derive the equation of a parabola given a focus and directrix, but students have limited opportunities to practice this standard.
- G-GMD.1.2: In Geometry, Lesson 3.4, students investigate the relationship between the volume formulas for a cylinder, cone, and hemisphere, in preparation for the derivation of the volume of a sphere using Cavalieri’s Principle. However, students do not practice using Cavalieri’s Principle in the student exercises.
- S-ID.1.4: In Algebra 2, Lessons 4.1 and 4.2, students use the empirical rule and standard normal calculations to determine probabilities. In Algebra 2, Lesson 4.3, students view normal versus non-normal data sets and determine the appropriateness of each. Students do not use spreadsheets and calculators when addressing this standard.
- S-ID.2.5: There were no problems found for students to practice joint and marginal relative frequencies in the materials.
Indicator 1c
The materials require students to engage in mathematics at a level of sophistication appropriate to high school.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series meet expectations for engaging students in mathematics at a level of sophistication appropriate to high school. The instructional materials regularly use age-appropriate contexts, use various types of real numbers, and provide opportunities for students to apply key takeaways from grades 6-8.
Examples where the materials regularly use age-appropriate contexts with various types of real numbers include:
- Algebra 1: In Lesson 2A.10, students organize a fundraising concert for their community. Students identify combinations of numbers, including decimals, to produce equivalent values. Throughout Lesson 2A.10, students work with integers and rational values.
- Algebra 1: In Lesson 5.2, students create a quadratic model to determine the path of a basketball. Students explore the reasonableness of decimal values related to measurement in feet.
- Geometry: In Lesson 3.3, students describe the building of a new observatory planned for a local college in terms of its basic geometric shapes. They also determine the volume of the dome of the building and other parts of the building.
- Geometry: In Lesson 2.13, students apply their knowledge of the Pythagorean Theorem and trigonometric ratios to calculate the distance from the roof a building to a windowsill where firefighters will need to descend by rope to enter the building. Students encounter decimal values to the thousandths place and make sense of the solution in context. Students work with rational and irrational numbers in this context.
- Algebra 2: In Lesson 3B.12, students use graphing technology to create exponential, linear, and quadratic functions for data sets representing the growth in users of a popular social media website. Students work with data sets representing millions of users, and as students choose a model, the values are written in scientific notation.
- Algebra 2: In Unit 2, Problem-Based Task 2.5, students determine the best wax for a surfboard. The method involves placing a block on the board and lifting the end. The sooner the block slides, the better the wax. Students work with decimal values and angles as they discover the angle that produces the best wax as seen by the movement of the block.
Examples where the materials regularly provide opportunities for students to apply key takeaways from grades 6-8 include:
- Algebra 1: In Lesson 2A.7, students apply their understanding of graphs (8.F.2.4) and begin to more formally describe various features. Students interpret key features from graphs and tables, as well as sketch graphs when given a verbal description.
- Geometry: Students apply proportions and ratios as key takeaways from grades 6-8 as they find arc lengths and areas of sectors in Lessons 5.8 and 5.9. Students use the definition of a sector as the portion of a circle bounded by two radii and their intercepted arc to create and solve a proportion to find the area of the sector.
- Algebra 2: In Lessons 1A.1-3, students find sums and differences of complex numbers by applying their understanding of combining like terms (8.EE.3.7b) and the Commutative Property of Addition (6.EE.1.3).
Indicator 1d
The materials are mathematically coherent and make meaningful connections in a single course and throughout the series, where appropriate and where required by the Standards.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series meet expectations for being mathematically coherent and making meaningful connections in a single course and throughout the series. The instructional materials foster coherence through meaningful mathematical connections in a single course and throughout the series, where appropriate and where required by the Standards.
Examples where the materials foster coherence through meaningful mathematical connections in a single course include:
- Algebra 1: In Lesson 1.3, students create linear equations in context (A-CED.1.1). In Lesson 1.6, students extend creating linear equations to creating and graphing linear equations in two variables (A-CED.1.2). In Lesson 1.10, students solve linear equations, and in Lesson 2B.6, students continue the progression of solving linear equations as they solve systems of linear equations through substitution and elimination (A-REI.3.5).
- Algebra 2: In Lessons 1B.3-5, students add, subtract, multiply, and divide rational expressions (A-APR.4.7). Students extend their understanding of rational expressions as they solve rational equations in Lessons 1B.6 (A-REI.1.2). In lessons 1B.8, students graph rational functions (F-IF.3.7).
- Geometry: In Lessons 1A.6 and 1A.7, students encounter properties of congruence within geometric figures (G-CO.2.6). In Lesson 2.4, students work with similar figures (G-SRT.2.4). In Lessons 2.6 and 2.8, students determine how side lengths of similar figures are proportional instead of congruent (G-SRT.2.5).
Examples where the materials foster coherence through meaningful mathematical connections throughout the series include:
- In Algebra 1, Lessons 2B.6 and 2B.7, students solve systems of linear equations (A-REI.3.7). In Algebra 1, Lessons 4.19 and 4.20, students extend that knowledge to solving systems of linear and quadratic equations. In Algebra 2, Lessons 1B.10-12, students review solving systems of equations graphically and extend that knowledge to rational and radical equations.
- In Geometry, Lesson 2.7, students extend their understanding of the Pythagorean Theorem as they prove it through the application of similarity (G-SRT.2.4). In Algebra 2, Lesson 2.5, students apply the Pythagorean Theorem to trigonometric identities.
- Transformations are found throughout the series. In Algebra 1, Lesson 2B.4, students transform linear and exponential functions. In Algebra 1, Lessons 5.17 and 5.18, students transform quadratic functions. In Geometry, Lessons 1A.4 and 1A.5, students use rotations, reflections, and translations in their work with transformations. In Algebra 2, Lesson 3B.7, students work with transformations of parent functions.
Indicator 1e
The materials explicitly identify and build on knowledge from Grades 6--8 to the High School Standards.
The instructional materials reviewed for the Walch Traditional Florida series meet expectations for explicitly identifying and building on knowledge from Grades 6-8 to the High School Standards. The standards from Grades 6-8 are explicitly identified in the Introduction and Key Concept, and the materials build on prerequisite knowledge. Examples where the materials identify standards and build on them include:
- In Algebra 1, lesson 1A.1, students translate verbal expressions into algebraic expressions and use order of operations (6.EE.2) to simplify algebraic expressions (A-SSE.1.1).
- In Algebra 1, Lesson 5.1, students extend the properties of integer exponents (8.EE.1.1) when simplifying expressions with rational exponents (N-RN.1.2).
- In Algebra 1, Lesson 2A.8, students use their previous learning of reading and interpreting data from charts and tables (6.EE.3.9) and understanding slope (8.EE.2.5) to calculate average rate of change of a function over a specified interval given a graph. Students also compare rates of change over various intervals (F-IF.2.6).
- In Geometry, Lesson 2.1, students apply operations with fractions (7.NS.1.1,2) and operations with fractions and decimals (7.EE.2.3) to calculate scale factors for similar figures (G-SRT.1.2).
- In Geometry, Lesson 2.10, students apply the Pythagorean Theorem (8.G.2.7) and ratios (7.RP.1.3) to solve problems involving trigonometric ratios and right triangles (G-SRT.3.6).
- In Geometry, Lesson 5.8, students find the circumference of circles (7.G.2.4) to find arc lengths (G-C.2.5).
- In Algebra 2, Lesson 3.1, students find the median and quartiles of a data set (6.SP.2.5) to construct box plots (S-ID.1.1).
Indicator 1f
The plus (+) standards, when included, are explicitly identified and coherently support the mathematics which all students should study in order to be college and career ready.